Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Crimes of the South African Police Service

Police spend R81m on trips
May 17 2012 at 10:32am
By Gaye Davis

INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS
Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa. Photo: Courtney Africa
Police officials splurged more than R80 million during the past financial year on trips overseas, but the Department of Police is refusing to give further details.
Information provided by the department, and revealed by Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa on Wednesday, said a total of 919 SAPS officials undertook 218 overseas trips during the 2011/12 financial year.
The total bill was R81 441 798 – which averages out to more than R88 000 for each official.
Daily allowances, which ran to a total of more than R24m, average out to more than R26 000 each.
The cost breakdown was as follows:
* Accommodation R22 959 409.
* Daily allowance R24 371 968.
* Transport R30 670 433.
* Food and beverages R206 558.
* “Incidental costs” R3 233 430.
Total: R81 441 798.
ANC MP Annelize van Wyk, a member of Parliament’s police oversight committee, wanted to know the names of each official who travelled, as well as the purpose and the outcome of every trip.
But in his written reply to her questions, Mthethwa does not provide the information.
It appears that the department, which his spokesman said had supplied the information, was coy about giving details.
The reply suggests that doing so might hamper ongoing criminal investigations.
Instead, Mthethwa’s reply makes vague reference to the trips as having included “attending Interpol-related matters”, regional meetings of police chiefs and subcommittees within the Southern African Development Community (SADC), conferences and training for peacekeeping and transnational crime, as well as “investigative matters”. Study tours, SADC election observer missions, UN peacekeeping meetings and EU security consultations were also listed.
Other trips were “of an operational nature where follow-ups are carried out within the context of organised crime and other criminal matters”.
“Given the fact that trips are inclusive of matters relating to investigations, and some of the investigations are still continuing, giving names of members and the outcome of each trip might have a negative impact towards resolving crimes that are being investigated.”
Mthethwa’s reply said that the outcome, or impact, of all the foreign travel “cannot be realised immediately”.
Mthethwa’s spokesman, Zweli Mnisi, said that this was an issue the minister might take a much closer look at in the near future.
From Page 1
“While we understand that our police officials will from time to time travel overseas, mainly to learn, interact and share expertise with their counterparts from other police departments worldwide, we equally believe that consideration of cost implications must be taken into account.
“We must, as a department, ensure that our expenditures are not exorbitant and that we are in line with government’s cost-saving principles of hair-cutting as announced by the finance minister.”
Van Wyk said she would be asking further questions about the spending and those who benefited from it.
Sapa reports that MPs held heated final deliberations on draft legislation to restructure the Hawks in line with a Constitutional Court judgment.
Opposition parties warned that the proposals would fail to satisfy the court. MPs were expected to vote on the bill last night. The original version tabled has been changed to give the members of the elite corruption-fighting unit greater security of tenure, and to limit the influence of the national police commissioner over it.
In the version set to go to the National Assembly the head will be appointed for between seven and 10 years. Although the head can still be removed by a vote in the National Assembly, Parliament’s portfolio committee on police has agreed this can be done only after an investigation headed by a sitting or retired judge.
These changes came about after experts told public hearings that the initial draft failed to satisfy the requirements of the Constitutional Court. - Political Bureau



Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Crimes of the South African Police Service

Black protester against the South African Police Service





https://www.google.co.za/search?q=south+african+police+service+brutality&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=3e_hUpj9KI6f7Abk74GwAw&ved=0CAcQ_AUoAQ&biw=1246&bih=923#facrc=_&imgdii=_&imgrc=e9IMN86a6atR1M%253A%3BP4PWbXIcBdCfIM%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fi.dailymail.co.uk%252Fi%252Fpix%252F2013%252F03%252F08%252Farticle-0-185FF959000005DC-546_634x457.jpg%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.dailymail.co.uk%252Fnews%252Farticle-2290213%252FSouth-Africa-angry-nation-brink-dangerous-warns-Nelson-Mandelas-wife.html%3B634%3B457



Crimes of the South African Police Service

Daveyton police station cells 'hell': resident
Sapa | 14 March, 2013 12:05



"If you have never been inside those (Daveyton) police station cells, you haven't seen anything," resident Martin Mokoena told him during a visit to the area.
Image by: SIMPHIWE NKWALI
The Daveyton police station cells are hell, a local resident told Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa on Thursday.
"If you have never been inside those (Daveyton) police station cells, you haven't seen anything," resident Martin Mokoena told him during a visit to the area.
Mthethwa and Gauteng police commissioner Mzwandile Petros were meeting with Daveyton residents following the death of taxi driver Mido Macia in police custody on February 26. Earlier that day he was dragged behind a police van.
Mthethwa listened and noted residents' complaints regarding the conduct of police in the area.
Mokoena, 50, said police "brutally" assaulted him in 2011 when he went to report his son, who broke his house's windows and doors. The son got angry after he reprimanded him for arriving home late one night.
"Instead they told me to go back. When I refused, they assaulted me and threw me into a cell."
Mokoena said he could not see properly and had difficulty hearing as a result of the assault. He went to see a doctor, and later went to open a case against the police.
"They told me I have to speak to the station commissioner if I have a complaint against the police, but an officer opened a docket and registered the complaint."
Mokoena said he had been following up on progress with the case, but nothing had been happening.
The nine policemen accused of killing Macia were denied bail by the Benoni Magistrate's Court on Tuesday.
Magistrate Sam Makamu said he felt it was not in the interests of justice to grant them bail. The matter would resume on April 12.
In delivering his ruling, Makamu said Daveyton residents could try to seek revenge on the accused. He expressed concern at the prospect of sending the men back to their homes in such an "unfavourable" climate.








Crimes of the South African Police Service

Police officer shoots girlfriend then himself



Police officer shoots girlfriend then himself Published: 2013 December 24 07:20:15  Warrant Officer Sachs Tlhowe Mothowagae based at the Mahikeng Organised Crime unit shot his 42-year-old girlfriend and then himself in South Africa.He was found alive inside a car at his sister's house in Welbedacht township near Zeerust but had apparently wounded himself through his mouth.He was taken to hospital where he later died.Earlier that morning, Mothowagae had reportedly gone to his 42-year-old girlfriend's house where they were last seen walking outside the house.A passer-by later found the woman who had been shot behind her right ear. - SAPA –

http://zimkasi.com/index-id-News-zk-18706.html

News Bites

Crimes of The South African Police Service

Cop fatally beats teenager over broken stove

Cop fatally beats teenager over broken stove Published: 2014 January 14 07:23:56 (Two 16-year-old boys, Makhosana Kasi and Mweli Sibaya picked up a broken, abandoned two-plate stove on their way to an all night vigil in Soweto, South Africa.It was a decision that cost Makhosana his life and put Mweli in hospital.It is alleged that at about 1am two men, one an off-duty Metro cop and the other his friend, stopped the two boys because they suspected they had stolen the small stove.The men allegedly made the boys lay down on the road and assaulted them repeatedly.Makhosana's sister, Phumzile Kasi, said her brother died at the scene at about 4am.The last time she saw him alive was on Friday night.The next time the family heard anything was when they were alerted at about 6am about the death of the teenager.Makhosana, a Grade 10 pupil at the Dr BW Vilakazi School, was described as a good child who loved people."He was always willing to run household errands and to help people," said his other sister, Lindi Kasi."What really hurts me is that even if suspects are arrested, their families can still visit them in jail - but we will never see our brother again."She said she wanted justice."I want justice to be served. My brother is not the first one to die because of law enforcement members who do just what they want to," she said.Makhosana's friend was taken to the Baragwanath hospital, but has since been released.Warrant Officer Kay Makhubela said two men, aged 30 and 38, were arrested and will appear in the Protea Magistrates Court today to face charges of assault and murder. - Politicsweb –

News Bites



Crimes of the South African Police Service

South Africa police brutality 932 people die in custody


South Africa police brutality - 932 people die in custody Published: 2013 March 04 21:42:57 The Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid) in South Africa has revealed that 932 people died in police custody in the country between 2011 and 2012.KwaZulu-Natal had 268 deaths with Gauteng second at 217 deaths and Eastern Cape had 120, according to the report.Meanwhile, eight police officers, implicated in the death of an East Rand taxi driver, are expected to appear in the Daveyton Magistrate's Court on Monday.The two warrant officers and six constables face a murder charge following the death of Mido Macia while in police custody.The officers allegedly tied 27-year-old Macia to the back of a police van and dragged him along a street in Daveyton on Tuesday.Macia, a taxi driver and Mozambican national, died at the local police station's cells several hours later. His body was found by a police officer on Tuesday night.A post mortem revealed he died of head and internal injuries.Ipid spokesman Moses Dlamini said police reported that they had earlier found Macia wrongfully parked on a road and ordered him to move.Macia's death caused a public outcry against police brutality.The Dispatch Online reported that the Ipid was also investigating the death of a policeman who died in police custody at the Barkly East police station in January, a day after he was detained for allegedly being drunk. - Sowetan –



Crimes of the South African Police Service



March 8 2013 Reprinted from Tia-MSOA who writes: "The fact that the criminal and murderer, Robert McBride, is still not behind bars yet is definite proof that there is something seriously wrong with South Africa’s justice system. On 8 April 2011, the Pretoria Magistrate's Court convicted McBride for drunken driving and defeating the ends of justice. His bail was extended, pending his sentencing on 15 July 2011. However, his sentencing only took place much later, in September 2011. He was then sentenced to two years imprisonment for driving under the influence of alcohol and an effective three years imprisonment for attempting to obstruct the course of justice. The later charge relates to McBride’s attempt at submitting a fraudulent medical certificate to the court. ( Reprinted from: " This is Africa, My Simple Online Abode: )
http://censorbugbear-reports.blogspot.com/2013/03/robert-mcbride-claims-victimisation.html


http://www.iol.co.za/the-star/mcbride-the-man-not-the-terrorist-1.1083316?ot=inmsa.ArticlePrintPageLayout.ot

Crimes of the South African Police Service


Robert McBride the man nominated by the SA Police Minister as new head of the IPID

Tuesday, 12 November 2013

His father Derrick Robert McBride and mother Doris were teachers at a Clairwood school. His maternal grandparents were Collin Campbell van Niekerk, a White Afrikaner, and Grace, a Coloured daughter of a Zulu-speaking mother and a Coloured father.

His father opens a workshop 'Utility Services'. At some point in 1978/79 his father begins burglar guards, fire-staircases and other light engineering steel work, where McBride assists. Robert is also involved in the collection of payment from customers, and has many encounters with gangs.

December 1980, Robert McBride receives his school leaving results, expecting high marks in Maths and Science. The results are poor and for the first time he stands up to his father, explaining the results by saying that he had to work for in the family business.

In 1981 McBride gains entrance to the University of Natal and begins studying Mechanical Engineering. He fails his first semester at university and subsequently drops out. He again works with his father for 3 months and then as a dock shiftworker for another 4 months.

Robert McBride works as an instrument fitter for Sasol for 6-7 months. He is trained at the oil parastatal's Secunda plant in the eastern Transvaal (now called Mpumalanga). Here he meets fellow worker Thomas Matjeke a trade unionist who talks often of the ANC and Frelimo.

McBride is badly burned in a gas bottle explosion at work and is hospitalized in Bethal. He is fetched by his father after an estrangement lasting several months. For the rest of the year he works with his father. Doris, Robert's mother, obtains a gun for protection against gang attacks. Prior to this Robert owned an illegal firearm.

McBride obtains a copy of the Bob Marley "Survival" album, banned in South Africa, and instantly relates to the revolutionary lyrics.

McBride gets close to Rashaad "Ricky" Leonard, a childhood acquaintance. Through him he is introduced to "Soledad Brothers - the prison letters of George Jackson", who was an African-American associated with the Black Panther movement. It becomes one of the most influential books McBride ever reads.

Mcbride enrols at Bechet (Coloured) Teacher Training College and gets elected to the Student's representative Council the same year.

Robert McBride assaults a plain-clothes policeman who, with 2 others, attempts to rob his mother's diner. Later, in a separate incident, he kills one of a group of attackers with his mother's pistol while returning from walking some of his mother's employees home at night. The assailant was a youth of about 18. He reports the matter to the local police station.

Robert McBride and other students form the Bechet branch of the Azanian Students' Organisation (AZASO), a student wing of the United Democratic Front (UDF). McBride meets Vincent James, active in the Congress of South African Students (COSAS).

In June 1986, an ANC armed terrorist wing, uMkhonto we Sizwe (MK) cell, led by Robert McBride, planted a bomb in a car outside the popular "Why Not" bar and Magoo's Bar on Durban’s busy beach-front. Three innocent defenceless women died and 71 were injured in the bomb explosion, which became known as the Magoo’s Bar bombing.

McBride taped together more than 100 pounds of explosives, attaching a mine with a 15-minute timer as his trigger, and swaddling this propulsive charge with bags of machine-gun bullets and metal scraps for shrapnel. He secreted his lethal contraption in the spare-wheel well of a powder-blue Ford Cortina, which he parked one busy Saturday night on a crowded beach-front esplanade in Durban.

McBride, the bomber, was out of earshot when his device exploded into two busy bars called Magoo's and the Why Not, killing three women, wounding 71 people, and inaugurating a new stage in the ANC's war against innocent South African civilians.

Robert McBride was sentenced to death three times for his part in the attack.

These acts of terrorist war against defenceless civilians still stands for many South Africans as a reason for withholding forgiveness and reconciliation.

In an interview with Bill Keller (1992), he noted with pride that South Africa's reconciliation process came close to breaking down over his case, which is remembered with particular horror by most.

South Africa's Constitutional Court ruled that McBride may be called a murderer, although he had received amnesty for the incident.

On March 9, 1998, (Four years after the ANC had taken over the government of the country), McBride, then a high-ranking official in the Department of Foreign Affairs, was arrested by the Mozambican police in Ressano Garcia, Mozambique, for allegedly smuggling weapons from Mozambique to South Africa. He maintained he was working with the South African National Intelligence Agency (NIA) and was later released by the Mozambican authorities. McBride was appointed Chief of the Metropolitan (metro) Police for Chief of Ekhuruleni Municipality in 2003.

On December 21, 2006, McBride rolled his vehicle at high speed on the R511 near Pretoria and witnesses at the scene said he appeared to be heavily intoxicated.

It did not help matters when the outspoken McBride, not known for keeping his temper, apparently threatened bystanders who were watching the drama unfold.

In an unexpected turn of events, three police officers - Patrick Johnston, Stanley Segathevan and Itumeleng Koko - who had hurried McBride away from the scene on that December 21 night in 2006, seemingly turned their backs on their old boss and obtained court interdicts protecting them, so they said, from McBride and other officials.

The Sunday Times reported (quoted here) that court was told of the following threat by McBride: 'If anyone of you co-operates with the police or gives any statements which directly incriminate me in any criminal activities I will rape your wives before I kill them, kill your children, and thereafter kill everything that moves at your homes, including your cats and dogs’.

Judge Moroa Tsoka ordered McBride to stop threatening, harassing and intimidating the three senior colleagues who allegedly gave damning evidence against him.

South Africa's Police Minister nominated Robert McBride for the position of head of the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid)

"We believe Mr McBride's appointment as head of Ipid will help this important institution to achieve [its]... mandate," the SA Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa said.

The minister added that, "Mr McBride was the successful candidate following the shortlisting, interviewing processes, as well as Cabinet's endorsement,"

The Minister said the SA Cabinet decided to recommend McBride as IPID executive director at a meeting on Wednesday 13 November 2013.

http://toxinews.blogspot.com/2013/11/robert-mcbride-man-nominated-by-the-sa.html


AfriForum pays homage to Magoo's bomb victims

Charl Oberholzer
14 June 2011

AfriForum today pays homage to the three people who died on this day 25 years ago in the ANC and Robert McBride's bomb attack on civilians at the Magoo's Bar in Durban.

Apart from the three women ‒ Angelique Pattenden, Julie van der Linde and Marchelle Gerand ‒ who died in the bombing, 71 other civilians were injured. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission ruled that the bombing had been a gross violation of human rights. Few, if any, of the victims were members of the security forces.

The Constitutional Court recently ruled that McBride may be called a murderer, although he had received amnesty for the incident.

"We don't approve of the history of young Afrikaners being criminalised, while the history of the ANC is romanticised," said Charl Oberholzer, National Chairperson of AfriForum Youth.

According to Oberholzer, it is important to commemorate the incident in the run-up to Youth Day in order to dispel the myth that the ANC' struggle was entirely noble and innocent.

"Our thoughts are with the next of kin of those victims who died and the 71 innocent victims who were injured in the blast," Oberholzer said.

The names of the victims are given below.

1.   D. Arnold

2.   Michael Blair

3.   J. Blair

4.   E. Booth

5.   D. Bret

6.   Kevin Byrne

7.   P. Byrom

8.   Christopher Clarkson

9.   M. Coeks

10. Jenny Cubbit

11. M. Cyrnow

12. A. de Chalain

13. Lorraine de la Rosa

14. L. Donaghue

15. F. Drummel

16. A. Duncan

17. Rajesh Durlcharan

18. Dennis Eaby

19. C. Edgar

20. K. English

21. B. Erasmus

22. E. Ethell

23. James Ferguson

24. R. Ferreira

25. R.M. Ferreria

26. Mr. Fiddler

27. Mrs. Fiddler

28. David Fletcher

29. L. Friar

30. B. Giddy

31. Carl Hadden

32. Paula Harvey

33. T. Hempstead

34. Keith Hulse

35. Jonathan Jeffers

36. S. Jeffries

37. I. Joao

38. Helen Kearney

39. C. Kenning

40. J. Kerlen

41. L. Koenig

42. E. Langridge

43. L. Livingstone

44. E. Maker

45. Gavin Maxwell

46. Victor Mchunu

47. John McKenna

48. H. Merval

49. S. Mintz

50. L. Mitchell

51. P. Mulholland

52. B. Newby-Fraser

53. C. Olds

54. L. Oliver

55. D. Pavillon

56. M. Plaatjies

57. W. Puttock

58. M. Rathbone

59. K. Robert

60. F. Robits

61. M. Roe

62. J. Saich

63. Roger Shillaw

64. A. Strydom

65. P. Swart

66. G. Tonetti

67. A. van Wyk

68. T. Vilonel

69. L. Valentine

70. L. Waterworth

71. I. Walton

Statement issued by Charl Oberholzer, AfriForum Youth national chairperson, June 14 2011

http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page72308?oid=240990&sn=Detail&pid=72308













Crimes of the South African Police Service


(Picture: Sapa)





Crimes of the South African Police Service

The Shocking Appointment of Robert McBride
31 January 2014, 06:53

Controversial Robert McBride Gets the IPID. Of all the many bad ANC appointments, the cadre deployment of Robert McBride to being the head of the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) is one of the worst. The SAPS continues to slide and with it so does South Africa. At moments such as these i battle to see a future for our country. In contrast, Zuma loyal, Marius Fransman, the ANC's Western Cape chairman, hailed McBride as "a hero, patriot and committed civil servant to the people of South Africa". Very disturbing start to South Africa's weekend!
Wikipedia: "Most well known was his leadership of the cell that bombed the "Why Not" Restaurant and Magoo's Bar in Durban on 14 June 1986, an attack in which three white women were killed and 69 people injured. He was captured and convicted for the Durban bombing, and sentenced to death, but later reprieved while on death row. In 1992, he was released after his actions were classified as politically motivated. He was later granted amnesty at the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) which provided for amnesty in return for complete disclosure of acts of politically motivated violence, after the ANC changed their early denials of involvement to a claim that they ordered the bombing.
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (South Africa) report stated "It seems that not many, if any, of the victims in this incident were members of the South African Police [the target]. Furthermore, the criticisms directed at the quality of reconnaissance of the "Why Not Bar" might very well be valid. It may be, as was argued, that he ought to have ensured at the relevant time that the primary targets of the attack were present and therefore the concept of the proportionality of the attack and its results must be considered." McBride and others were granted amnesty for the attack, although the commission did find the bombing to be a "gross violation of human rights".
Dianne Kohler Barnard says excision of legal qualification from advert for position, speaks to a pre-determined outcome...
With daily reports of police brutality, the last appointment that should ever have been made is that of the controversial Robert McBride as the Executive Director of the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID).
Today in Parliament the ANC majority in the Police Portfolio Committee supported Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa's bizarre nomination of McBride to head up the unit. It is yet another indication that Zuma's ANC is not serious about the fight against corruption or crime. After the disastrous appointments of Jackie Selebi and Bheki Cele, the DA believes the Minister should have chosen differently.
Robert McBride is not the right person for the job.
Firstly, McBride is deeply embedded and loyal to the ANC. The head of IPID must not be linked to any political party in order to investigate police officers, including politically-appointed top brass without fear or favour.
Secondly, the head of IPID needs to be free of controversy, in order to build public trust in his office.
McBride has in the past been involved in numerous scandals:
1. In 1998, McBride was arrested by the Mozambican police on charges of gun running;
2. In 1999, while in the company of underworld bosses at an escort agency, McBride was accused of assault; and
3. In 2011, McBride was convicted of drunken driving and attempting to obstruct justice, and sentenced to five years imprisonment. He was acquitted in April last year.
The DA will today write to Minister Mthethwa requesting that he reconsider the appointment of Robert McBride as IPID head. Should he refuse, the DA will write to President Jacob Zuma requesting that he stop the appointment. Should neither the Minister or the President intervene accordingly, the DA will consider pursuing legal action.
The DA is extremely disheartened by this appointment. That the advertisement for the post had the necessity for a legal qualification excised, speaks to a pre-determined outcome as it was seemingly tailored to McBride's CV. Confidence in the IPID is diminishing at a time when it is most crucial due to increases in police brutality. This appointment is even more disturbing when taking into consideration that since the start of January, approximately eight civilians have been allegedly killed by police. IPID is responsible for investigating these incidences and holding police members to account.
Token appointments based on party affiliation, especially in the security services, is not in the best interest of the public. Zuma's ANC has delivered a major blow to the fight against crime, corruption and police brutality. We will not let this go unanswered without a fight.
Statement issued by Dianne Kohler Barnard MP, DA Shadow Minister of Police, January 29 2014