Sunday, December 1, 2013

Crimes of the South African Police Service



Majority of SA thinks police are corrupt
July 12 2013 at 09:58am

Pretoria - A staggering 83 percent of South Africans believe the police are corrupt, Transparency International has revealed.
In its Global Corruption Barometer 2013, released this week, Transparency International said South Africa was among 36 countries in which the police were seen as the most corrupt institution.
“About 83 percent of South Africans believed that police were corrupt. Thirty-six percent admitted to having paid bribes to police,” the report said.
DA shadow minister of police Dianne Kohler-Barnard said she was surprised that such a high number of ordinary South Africans believed that the police were corrupt.
“However, on reflection, I am not surprised that so many people believe the police are corrupt,” she said on Thursday.
She said the murder in broad daylight of people such as taxi driver Mido Macia and activist Andries Tatane by the police was clearly indicative of the kind of police force South Africa had.
“Police demand bribes each time they stop a car, and they threaten those who refuse to pay bribes.
“Police steal from houses of victims of crime when they go to their houses to get statements from the victims.
“This is not surprising as thousands of police officers have criminal records,” Kohler-Barnard said.
Read more…..
http://www.iol.co.za/news/crime-courts/majority-of-sa-thinks-police-are-corrupt-1.1545776















Crimes of the South African Police Service

South African Police Kill Defenceless Man
Apr 13, 2011 

Protester Against Bad Service Delivery beaten and shot to death by South African Police

 
 shocking images as police shown beating defenceless protester to death.








Crimes of the South African Police Service

South African Police Kill Defenceless Man
Apr 13, 2011 

Protester Against Bad Service Delivery beaten and shot to death by South African Police

 Shocking images as police shown beating defenceless protester to death.









Crimes of the South African Police Service

South African Police Kill Defenceless Man
Apr 13, 2011 

Protest leader Against Bad Service Delivery beaten and shot to death by South African Police

Shocking images as police shown beating defenceless protester to death.











Crimes of the South African Police Service

Police Stop Democratic March by Democratic Alliance and concerned Citizens

The 248 million rand Nkandlagate Spectacle




Nkandla - DA leader Helen Zille has laid a charge under the Gatherings Act against the ANC for blocking a public road during her failed attempt to visit President Jacob Zuma's KwaZulu-Natal homestead.




When the convoy transporting the Democratic Alliance and a media contingent left the satellite police station, African National Congress supporters shouted "hamba" (leave).

Zille said Zuma had lost the right to call his home a private residence.

"Nkandla belongs to each and every South African who has to sacrifice the basic services they need, so that the President could turn his home into a five-star fortressed palace.

"One day we will look at it as a monument to the fight against corruption."

Violence

She questioned how the government could spend R248m on Zuma's home, when it would not pay to transport the relatives of the victims of the Marikana shooting to the Farlam commission of inquiry.

Earlier police stopped her and her entourage from approaching Zuma's homestead



Zille was told she could not pass the police roadblock as there were ANC supporters on the road to Zuma's home. She said the party had permission to gather on a public road outside a school opposite Zuma's home.

Several cars carrying ANC supporters passed the police roadblock on a side road. They carried sticks and sang Dubhula iBhunu (Shoot the Boer).


Riot police

When Zille asked officers why they were allowed to pass, she was told they would open a case against the organisers of the ANC march.


http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/Politics/Zille-lays-charge-after-Nkandla-stand-off-20121104

Crimes of the South African Police Service


NW policewoman arrested for killing Kleinbooi Matthews, 20, Engen Garage, Klerksdorp
13:39 Jul 21 2012 Klerksdorp, NW

21 juli 2012 Policewoman arrested for murdering Kleinbooi Matthews:

July 20 2012 North West - A North West police constable was arrested on Friday after she allegedly killed a man by throwing him from a moving car, the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) said.

The 32-year-old policewoman from Jouberton, in Klerksdorp, allegedly killed 20-year-old Kleinbooi Matthews on Sunday, IPID spokesman Moses Dlamini said in a statement.

“A group of youths were walking from a nearby tavern on the way home. A police vehicle stopped near an Engen garage and the driver of the police vehicle (the constable) called the victim to the police vehicle,” he said.

“It is alleged that the driver... then closed the window of the police vehicle and drove away while the victim's head was inside. The rest of the victim's body was dangling outside.”

He said the window was then opened and the man was thrown to the road.
Paramedics declared him dead at the scene

The constable would appear in the Klerksdorp Magistrate's Court on Monday. – Sapa






Crimes of the South African Police Service


Assault, false arrest in shakedown attempts by 2 Sandton police officers “


Description
Ashley Cerqueira, Bryanston resident, targetted twice for assault, false arrest in shakedown attempts by 2 SANDTON police officers –

Eyewitness news 4 June - two Sandton police officers are under investigation for assault and wrongful arrest.

Both of the incidents were captured on CCTV camera and show white Bryanston resdent Ashley Cerqueira pulled over, assaulted and pepper sprayed.

The first time they claimed inaccurately he was drink, shortly thereafter they claimed he possessed illegal marijuana.

Cerqueira said the cops wanted his cellphone because he had recorded a conversation in which they were trying to shake him down for a bribe.

The independent police investigative directorate spokesman Moses Dlamni said the matter was being investigated. They have taken over the docket from the police.

Mr Cerqueira was NEVER charged for any offences.

Clare Matthes - http://www.ewn.co.za/en/2012/06/04/Unruly_Sandton_Police_caught_on_camera.aspx

Read more at …..


Crimes of the South African Police Service

Shopkeeper ‘manhandled by police’
October 29 2013 at 02:54pm
By NKULULEKO NENE

INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS
An emotional Feng Hui Lin, speaking at the Chinese consulate, described the alleged discrimination by KwaDukuza traffic police. Picture: Gcina Ndwalane
Durban - A Chinese businessman has claimed that an angry KwaDukuza traffic officer allegedly pepper-sprayed him after he asked a motorist who was parked in front of his supermarket to move so that a truck could off-load goods.
The officer’s woman partner then allegedly pointed a firearm at him, said Feng Hui Lin, who has laid charges of assault and pointing of a firearm against the officers.
He claimed he was locked up for four hours in a “container” at the traffic police department’s yard last Tuesday.
The 34-year-old owner of the “5 Cents” supermarket in the North Coast town’s King Shaka Street, has also reported his alleged ordeal to the Chinese consulate.
Speaking to the Daily News outside the consulate offices in Durban North, Lin said he was shocked at the way the South African police treated foreigners, claiming he was discriminated against because of his nationality.
Explaining last week’s events, he said the motorist had agreed to move his car from outside his shop when the police intervened.
The two KwaDukuza traffic officers told the motorist to ignore him, he said, adding that as the driver was reversing, he bumped into him.
“I asked an apologetic driver to watch where he was driving. Suddenly, an officer pulled out from nowhere and shouted to me, ‘This is not China.’
“He grabbed me by the collar while swearing at me. He pepper sprayed me so bad I could not see a thing,” he said.
“I tried to wipe it using my hand, but it got worse. I went inside the shop with an aim to wash my eyes,” he said.
Lin said when he bent over the washbasin, his firearm that was tucked into his waistband became visible, prompting the female officer to pull out a rifle, which she allegedly pointed at his face.
“I was humiliated in front of my wife, staff, and customers,” he said. Another businessman tried to intervene, but the cops would hear none of it.”
Lin said more police arrived and tackled him. He was allegedly handcuffed and thrown into the police car. When he asked an officer why he was being arrested, he was told it was for pulling out a firearm.
“Instead of locking me up at a nearby SAPS station, I was kept for four hours at a container in the traffic police department yard,” said Lin.
“I felt discriminated (against) because of my nationality,” he said. “The consulate (official) told me that she will report the matter in Pretoria on her next visit.”
Lin said he had seen a doctor after his ordeal.
A former Stanger councillor, Rabi Singh, who runs a nearby shop, said he had witnessed the incident and tried to intervene. He said he was also threatened with arrest.
“I asked why they were abusing the man. They asked me what I was going to do… I went to my shop and tried to call the KwaDukuza mayor (Ricardo Mthembu), but was told he had a meeting,” he said.
Singh said he felt sorry for Lin, who he described as a humble man.
SAPS spokesman Captain Thulani Zwane confirmed a charge of pointing a firearm had been laid against the traffic officer at the KwaDukuza police station. There was no record of an assault charge.
He said investigations were continuing.
KwaDukuza municipality spokesman, Sifiso Zulu, on Monday said no complaint had been lodged with the municipality, but the council would issue a statement once the SAPS investigation had been concluded.
nkululeko.nene@inl.co.za
Daily News
http://www.iol.co.za/news/crime-courts/shopkeeper-manhandled-by-police-1.1599029






Crimes of the South African Police Service

Police crimes soar in SA
October 2 2013 at 03:14pm
By SIHLE MLAMBO AND MARIANNE MERTEN


Durban - Police in KwaZulu-Natal were investigated for 772 alleged crimes in the past financial year, including 24 rapes and 146 deaths, the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid), has revealed.
Read more….
sihle.mlambo@inl.co.za
Daily News
http://www.iol.co.za/news/crime-courts/police-crimes-soar-in-sa-1.1586051






Crimes of the South African Police Service

Update: Pregnant woman allegedly punched by Metro cop
A pregnant woman is allegedly punched in the stomach, and her family claims to be called 'kulas' - a racist term for 'Indians' - by JMPD.
06 September 2012 | Mlungisi Mabaso
null
Not rated yet.
Update - September 6, 2012, 10.09am - JMPD spokesperson Wayne Minnaar says that it is illegal to have any goods outside a store.
He added that no report has come to JMPD's attention of the pregnant woman being punched in the stomach.
Update - September 4, 2012, 12.50pm: JMPD spokesperson Wayne Minnaar said that he has to check up on the Amazon Pets incident.
Initial report - August 30, 2012, 3.56pm: A pregnant woman was allegedly punched by a female Johannesburg Metro Police Department (JMPD) cop during a commotion between shop keepers and the officials.
The incident transpired on August 18 at Amazon Pets in Lenasia, Ext 1. JMPD officials reportedly confisticated goods that was illegally displayed or belonged to people trading in the street.
The owner of the shop, who did not want to be named, stated that the goods confisticated were not on the floor but hung on the shop wall; which is not illegal trading.
Her daughter, who is about four months pregnant, was allegedly punched in the stomach. She has since suffered pains.
Hashim Ismail, the shop keeper’s son was arrested, detained and charged for defeating the ends of justice; he was released after four hours.
"We were called ‘kulas’, which is racist. We are not letting this lie down," said the aggravated shop keeper. She added they will be contacting a certain organisation, to take up the matter.
JMPD could not be reached for comment.

https://www.facebook.com/pages/South-African-Police-Are-Rapists/208430035905750

Crimes of the South African Police Service


Policewoman Arrested for Murder



Crimes of the South African Police Service

Prominent security consultant Paul O'Sullivan charged after helping police arrest alleged crime-kingpin Zunaid Moti



11:25 Aug 1 2012 Brits

Prominent security consultant Paul O'Sullivan charged after helping police arrest alleged crime-kingpin Zunaid Moti

August 1 2012 at 11:29am Security consultant Paul O'Sullivan charged for helping arrest accused crime-king pin Zunaid Moti outside the Germiston Magistrates Court.

 Picture Antoine de Ras Johannesburg - Three criminal cases were opened at the Bramley police station, reportedly against a prominent security consultant, Gauteng police said on Wednesday.“Two are of intimidation and one is crimen injuria,” said Lieutenant-Colonel Lungelo Dlamini. “We can't name the suspect as yet as he has not appeared in court.”He said three people claimed they were verbally threatened but he could not provide further details.

Eyewitness News reported that the cases were against consultant Paul O'Sullivan, and were lodged on Sunday by security guards working for "business tycoon" Zunaid Moti . Moti appeared in the Brits Regional Court in mid-July on charges of armed robbery and conspiracy to commit murder.

He was granted bail of R40000. His co-accused Carlos de Sousa, who appeared on charges of assault, armed robbery and kidnapping, was released on bail of R30 000. Moti, the owner of a luxury vehicle dealership, handed himself in at the Hartbeespoort police station earlier in July and De Sousa was arrested in Johannesburg.Moti is also the chairman of property group Abalengani. – Sapa

http://www.iol.co.za/news/crime-courts/charges-laid-against-security-consultant-1.1353863#.UBmMOKAprd4




Crimes of the South African Police Service

Attempted farm attack: Rheenendal, Knysna, black male in police uniform arrested


11:12 Sep 1 2012 Knysna
Description
Attempted farm attack in Rheenendal, Knysna by a black male in police uniform:
KNYSNA - A black male suspect who the SAPS said had posed as a police officer, was apprehended following an attempted armed robbery incident at a house on a farm near Rheenendal.

His alleged accomplice had fled the scene.According to Constable Chris Spies, SAPS media liaison, rapid response from members of the Knysna police led to the arrest of the suspect at the Rheenendal road near Knysna on Saturday, September 1.

"The suspect was arrested after members of the police were informed about an attempted armed robbery at a house on a farm near Rheenendal. It is alleged that the suspects knocked on the door of the house and identified themselves as members of the police," explained Spies. A suspect whohad posed as a police officer, was apprehended following an attempted armed robbery incident at a house on a farm near Rheenendal. His alleged accomplice had fled the scene.

According to Constable Chris Spies, SAPS media liaison, rapid response from members of the Knysna police led to the arrest of the suspect at the Rheenendal road near Knysna on Saturday, September 1.

"The suspect was arrested after members of the police were informed about an attempted armed robbery at a house on a farm near Rheenendal. It is alleged that the suspects knocked on the door of the house and identified themselves as members of the police," explained Spies.

http://www.knysnaplettherald.com/news.aspx?id=35668&utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter







Crimes of the South African Police Service

SA police brutality: Amnesty International publishes list of blacks-only police-victims 2012 


04:33 Oct 14 2012 Johannesburg



SA Police brutality 2012: Amnesty International publishes an incomplete report showing only a few dozen black victims of police-criminality:
========================================
"Amnesty International has expressed concerns about police brutality, including torture and extrajudicial killings, in South Africa.[18][19] There has also been concern about brutal training methods for the police.[20] According to Peter Jordi from the Wits Law Clinic "[Police] Torture is spiralling out of control. It is happening everywhere."[21] In April 2012 an editorial in The Times opined that "It seems torture and outright violation of human rights is becoming the order of the day for some of our police officers and experts warn that the line between criminals and our law enforcement officers is "blurred"."[23]

Political repression

A number of community organisations and social movements have accused the SAPS of acting against them with illegality and brutality.[25][26][27][28] Independent studies have confirmed that the SAPS has been used to repress peaceful marches and freedom of association.[29]

In 27 April 2009, SAPS attempted to ban a well-known event among the social movements called unFreedom Day[30] and was implicated in support for September 2009 ANC mob that attacked the elected leadership of the shack settlement at Kennedy Road, Durban.[31][32][33]

SAPS has also been implicated in draconian policing measures. Numerous accusations come from the infamous Blikkiesdorp Temporary Relocation Area in Delft, Cape Town where police have been accused of suppression of freedoms and illegal curfews.[34][35][36]

  
A number of unarmed protestors have been killed by the South African Police since 2000.
the following list is not complete:

Michael Makhabane Durban, 2000[37]

Dennis Mathibithi (17) and Nhlanhla Masuku (15), Kathlehong, 2004[38]

Tebogo Mkhonza (17), Harrismith, 2004[39]

Monica Ngcobo, (19) Durban, 2005[40]

Unnamed Man, Kenville, Durban, 2006[41]

Jan Matshobe, (27) Sebokeng, Johannesburg, 2008[42]

Mthokozisi Nkwanyana, (24) Durban, 2008 [43]

Unnamed girl, KwaZakhele, KwaZulu-Natal, 2009[44]

Phuphu Mthwethwa (29), Piet Retief, 2009[45]

Priscilla Sukai (46) eTwatwa, Daveyton, 2010[46]

Unnamed man, Lion Park, Johannesburg, 2010[47]

Anna Nokele (19), Welkom, 2010[48]

Two unnamed children, Boipelo, Gauteng, 2011[49][50]

Solomon Madonsela[51] and Bongani Mathebula[52] Ermelo, 2011[53]

Joseph Msiza, Tshwane, 2011[54][55]

Petros Msiza (43), 2011 Pretoria[56]

Andries Tatane (33), Ficksburg, 2011[39]

Dimakatso Kgaswane and another unnamed person, Tlokweng, Swartruggens,
2011[57]

Three unnamed people in KwaDukuza, KwaZulu-Natal, 2011[58]

Mxolisi Buthelezi, (14), Durban, 2012 (an onlooker, not a protester)[59]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_Police_Service#Police_brutality






Crimes of the South African Police Service

Two Afrikaans-speaking coloured youths, 17 and 19, die in SAPS cell Hawston: six police vehicles torched in spontaneous protests


10:13 Nov 4 2012 Hawston, WC

Description
Six police vans burnt after two Hawston residents die in SAPS cell after riot Nov 3 2012
Fishing rights Hawston: http://www.prem-online.org/archive/1/doc/PREM%20SA%20fisheries%20project%20report%20wout%20append.pdf
For Background on the battle waged by the traditional residents of Hawston over their fishing rights, and the overfishing done by the #tenderpreneurs who contract with the Dept of Fishereries: read Free University of Amsterdam report:
"Fisheries, Poverty and Politics in South Africa (168p):

http://www.prem-online.org/archive/1/doc/PREM%20SA%20fisheries%20project%20report%20wout%20append.pd
www.prem-online.org

Hawston residents contacted me and said the situation there is much more serious than reported by EWN."This place is a dirty gangster-mecca where people can get anything they want by using violence. The EWN report claims no-one was injured - however a...See
It was just announced on the news that a 17-year-old Afrikaans-speaking coloured child has died in police custody in Hawston.
http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=160602670753135&set=a.107737062706363.16434.100004102094863&type=1&theater

THE EARLIER REPORT BY EWN WAS INACCURATE: "awston fishing community - long engaged over fishing-rights with #ANC tenderpreneurs and #Dept of Fisheries - explode in anger over death of teenage fisherman:

LINK TO REPORT:
http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=160595814087154&set=a.107737062706363.16434.100004102094863&type=1&theater background:

BACKGROUND ON BATTLE FOR FISHING RIGHTS BETWEEN TRADITIONAL COLOURED AFRIKAANS SPEAKING RESIDENTS OF HAWSTON AND THE DEPT OF FISHERIES AND THEIR TENDER-ENTREPRENEURS: official report by Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam: http://www.prem-online.org/archive/1/doc/PREM%20SA%20fisheries%20project%20report%20wout%20append.pdf







Crimes of the South African Police Service

Afrikaner dad Charlie Niemann 26 arrested with 3yo daughter Cherise: police threatened to throw her in cell if she didn't stop crying

09:52 Feb 3 2013 Hazeyview, Lowveld

Afrikaner Charlie Niemann 26 arrested with three-year-old daughter Cherise in SAPS cell while buying milk -- 2013-02-03 In yet another of the many incidents in which Afrikaners are suffering false arrests with trumped up driving charges, 26-year-old Afrikaner dad - while admitting he'd had two beers a few hours earlier - had gone to the shops to buy milk with his little 3-year-old girl Cherise when he was pulled over by cops in Hazyview. The barefoot Cherise was in his car with him, wearing only her pyjamas. writes Vania van der Heever of Rappoort weekly.

He was arrested for 'drunk driving' but denied being drunk when he drove to the cafe. Police officers grabbed him and the girl and took the toddler to the police station with him - and threw them in a police cell together. It's illegal in South Africa to put a small child in a police cell. They refused to take the child home nor let the dad make a phone call to have her fetched. “It was terrible. My child was hysterical. The officials were inhuman. They even refused to give her water. When we got there and Cherise was crying, one threatened to throw her in a police cell if I couldn’t get her to calm down.”His wife, Stephanie, 30, pregnant with the couple’s second child, said she expected the worst when the two didn’t come back from the café.

We have taken Cherise to a counsellor and she is getting better. But she is scared of police officers. Whenever she sees a police car, she looks for her dad and starts crying hysterically.” Niemann has laid a charge against the police with the independent complaints directorate.
A police spokesperson said it was illegal to lock up a child in a police cell.
It's not known what has become of the 'drunk driving charge' nor whether Mr Niemann was even tested.

http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Girl-3-locked-in-police-cell-20130203




Crimes of the South African Police Service

ANC-regime is turning South Africa into its infamous Camp Quatro exile torture camp: with 294 deaths in police custody last year...


11:47 Mar 5 2013 Luthuli House, Johannesburg

After twenty years under the ANC-regime all of South Africa is being turned into the ANC's nfamous Camp Quatro torture camp where there is no accountability for cruelties, torture and terror: Paul Trewhela writes- 1 March 2013 - "After nearly 20 years of ANC government, Camp Quatro was the 'model' of the ANC in exile, under the reign of terror of its secret police force, Mbokodo ("the grindstone."" Immune to demands for individual accountability of office-holders to their members, an arrogant, self-serving political elite responded in that period with ongoing harsh repression.

As confirmed in the final report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (1998), the killings of dissidents by Mbokodo (the grindstone) took place at will, while ANC members who refused to conform found themselves detained without trial for years at a time in Quatro prison camp in northern Angola, often enduring daily beatings and torture. This was the model for the licensed killings at Ficksburg, Marikana and now Daveyton," writes Paul Trewhela.

"SA's electoral system has left ordinary citizens powerless to stop abuses: - Paul Trewhela writes: "After the death in police hands in Daveyton this week of the Mozambican taxi driver, Mido Macia (27) - hauled handcuffed behind a moving police van before the eyes of the world on television news services yesterday - South Africa is today faced with the threat of a Quatro state, with an unaccountable police force and an unaccountable political system.

Worldwide media interest in the violent death of model Reeva Steenkamp at the hands of her Olympic hero boyfriend, Oscar Pistorius, was succeeded yesterday by the front page of the Daily Sun, with its headline "Murdered by the South African Police Service", waved by angry citizens in Daveyton.Horrific footage has been shown on television, iPads and cellphones world-wide.It is now reported across the world that, according to Amnesty International, there were
294 deaths in police custody in South Africa in the 12 months before March 2010.

This appalling statistic relates to a period more than two years before the police killings at Marikana last August, preceded as these were by the killing by police -again, on film - of Andries Tatane at Ficksburg in April 2011. Inmates at Daveyton police station have alleged that Macia was beaten to death by police in the cells, after having been dragged handcuffed to the back of a police van for several hundreds of metres. He was found dead in his cell on Tuesday.

Moses Dlamini, spokesman of the Independent Police Investigation Directorate, stated: "We are shocked by the footage which has been released."

Trewhela: "Instead of the civic and democratic constitutional system that South Africans and the world believed had been set in place by the reforms set in place under guidance of Emeritus President Mandela following his release from prison in 1990, the country now finds itself trapped in an unaccountable political system, with unaccountable police killings."
The manhandling and murderous abuse of Mido Macia this week in full public view gives point to increasing calls by eminent public figures in South Africa for a reform of the political system, so as to bring politicians under control of local communities.

Three of the most recent demands for electoral reform were made by Dr Mamphela Ramphele, announcing the formation of a new political party, Agang, which will place electoral reform at the head of its political programme (18 February); by the Cape Town-based political commentator and former Oxford academic, RW Johnson, in a long article on Politicsweb (17 February); and by the Catholic archbishop of Durban, Cardinal Wilfrid Napier (27 January).

In her address announcing the formation of Agang, "Rekindling the South African dream", Mamphela Ramphele stated that South Africa was being "fundamentally undermined by a massive failure of governance. Our rallying cry during the struggle for freedom was for the people to govern, yet the system of choosing Members of Parliament from lists drawn up by political parties gives disproportionate power to party bosses at the expense of ordinary citizens. We should be able to vote for the person in our own area we want to represent us in Parliament, so we can hold them accountable for the electoral promises they make.

"We want an MP for Marikana, an MP for De Doorns, and an MP for Sasolburg, so if the people are unhappy and the MP is not responsive enough, they will be voted out at the next election. South Africa's people are effectively being prevented from governing by the country's electoral system. We will be working with fellow citizens to launch a million signature campaign for electoral reform. Electoral reform must be the first order of business of the post-2014 election parliament."

Just as there is no MP for Marikana, De Doorns or Sasolburg under the current electoral law, so the citizens of Ficksburg and now Daveyton find themselves powerless to insist on justice in the face of police lawlessness.

In his article, "The state of the opposition", RW Johnson has similarly emphasised that "South Africa's bizarre electoral system ... removes all accountability to voters from MPs and hands all power to the party bosses", noting that more and more voices were being raised "against our appalling electoral system."

In the same way, in an article in the Sunday Independent headed "Speaking truth will set our country free", Cardinal Wilfrid Napier made a searching criticism of the lack of democratic representation under what he descibed as "party list system".
The principal problem with the list system, he wrote, is that "candidates chosen to represent the electorate are failing in their task because they are beholden to the party which can promote or demote them at will and without reference to their performance in the eyes of those they are supposed to serve."

It is high time, he added, that "the findings of the Slabbert Commission [of 2003, into electoral reform] were dusted off, studied, debated and put into practice."
Trewhela: "All the more urgently, after the shameless killing of Mido Macia, should these sound and sober criticisms of an increasingly dictatorial political system be 'studied, debated and put into practice,' as Cardinal Napier has urged.

The alternative, already showing its flagrant brutality, is the Quatro state.

http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page72308